|
| |
 |
|---|
|
iPhone/iPod Touch Program “Radiation
Passport” Estimates Radiation/Cancer Risks from Radiology and Related
Examinations and Procedures - 2009 | |
By Mark Otto
Baerlocher, MD
|
 |
|
Mark Otto Baerlocher, MD
Toronto, Ontario,Canada
mark.baerlocher@utoronto.ca |
The recent articles published in the
Archives of Internal Medicine (Arch Intern Med.
2009;169[22]:2078-2086, 2071-2077), and several previous recent
articles in the New England Journal of Medicine (N Engl J
Med. 2007 Nov 29;357(22):2277-84; N Engl J Med. 2009 Aug
27;361(9):849-57) have led to a slew of new headline stories in the
international media, and have further brought the issue of radiation
risk from Radiology and related examinations and procedures into the
spotlight. Like it or not, this issue is here to stay, and as
radiologists are the physicians with the greatest knowledge of
radiation safety issues, we must explore its consequences in a very
detailed and in-depth manner.
While it is well-accepted that radiation is not innocuous, and may
lead to the development of cancer, it is quite difficult to estimate
the size of this risk. There are a number of different models used
to do this. Arguably the best, or most complete, is that used by the
Biological Effects of Ionizing Radiation (BEIR) committee of the
U.S. National Academy of Sciences (NAS). The BEIR Committee follows
the ‘linear, non-threshold’ model when determining cancer risk from
radiation exposure. This means that all radiation, no matter how
small, has some risk and second, if a certain amount of radiation is
associated with a given risk, then half that radiation is associated
with approximately half the risk. The risks are also assumed to be
‘additive’ – the more radiation you are exposed to, the greater your
risk.
The risk estimates for many common procedures and examinations may
be higher than what many people realize. For example, the estimated
risk of developing fatal cancer specifically due to the radiation a
young woman is exposed to during a single CT scan of the abdomen is
estimated to be somewhere in the neighborhood of 1/800 to 1/2000,
depending on the settings of the CT Scanner. Older patients,
overall, have a decreased risk for a given new exposure.
A recent highly cited paper by Dr. Brenner and Dr. Hall published in
the New England Journal of Medicine suggested that up to 1.5
to 2% of all cancers in the US may become attributable to radiation
from CT scans if current usage rates continue.
Radiation Passport for the iPhone and iPod
Touch
Mark Otto Baerlocher has teamed up with his brother, who started
Tidal Pool Software to create a program – Radiation
Passport - for the iPhone and iPod Touch that is meant to be
useful for physicians and other healthcare professionals, as well as
patients.
Radiation Passport allows physicians and other healthcare
professionals to enter the age and gender of their patient, and the
specific examination (modality and body part), and receive an
estimate of the average associated radiation dose, and associated
risk of developing cancer (total, and fatal cancers separately). The
idea is that this information may then be used in part to help the
physician know the estimated risk and thereby better judge the
risk-benefit profile of ordering the examination, as well as helping
to answer any patient’s questions about the radiation risk
(particularly important, given the increasing frequency with which
this topic is now in the international news).
Radiation Passport also lets patients ‘track’ their radiation
exposure from medical examinations and procedures. Users enter the
type of examination they had, when they had it, and Radiation
Passport will record the examination and date, and assign the
estimated radiation exposure associated with their specific
examination. The radiation exposure is then summed for all
examinations and procedures entered, and an estimate of the cancer
risk due to the radiation exposure is calculated. Patients can also
write notes (for example, reminders that they need to follow-up on
their Radiology examination, or have a repeat examination in e.g. 12
months), and figure out the estimated risk of developing cancer for
a single Radiology or related examination or procedure they are
prescribed to undergo by their physician or dentist.
The overall goal of Radiation Passport is to increase awareness and
education among patients about the potential risks of medical
radiation. Radiology and radiology-related examinations and
procedures have been responsible for tremendous and very rapid
advances in the diagnosis and treatment of diseases. When these
examinations and procedures are considered necessary, it is assumed
that the potential benefit of the examination or treatment outweighs
the potential risk. This program aims to serve as a reminder to be
aware that there are assumed risks.
|
|---|
|
Note from
Radiology Malaysia:
This program sounds useful, but the dose estimates must be interpreted
with care especially by the public. Sounding alarm bells may stop a
patient from having a potentially important examination that will affect
the management of a patient’s condition and disease. Although the risks
may sound alarming, they are theoretical risk estimates, and may not
always correlate in reality with the true incidence of fatal cancers. In
addition, clinical judgement is all about benefits versus risks versus
costs and the evaluation of these may be beyond the understanding of the
patient without adequate counseling from the
physician/doctor/radiologist.
It will definitely create awareness amongst physicians who are less
aware of the radiation doses involved in many investigations utilizing
ionizing radiation. Physicians should also discuss the need for such
investigations especially on a repeat basis with their radiologists, and
alternatives should be considered where radiation is not involved.
Used properly, this tool may add value to decision making and remind all
– patients and doctors of the theoretical radiation risks. As always,
ensure the examination is justified, and then, the examination optimized
and dose limited as much as possible.
Mark Otto Baerlocher is a final year resident in the University of
Toronto, Canada. Next year, he will start his interventional radiology
fellowship in San Diego. He would like to get
feedback from those who have tested this application.
For further information, as well as previous media stories about
Radiation Passport, please see:
http://www.tidalpool.ca/radiationpassport/index.html
|
|---|
|
|
>>>
Click Here to return to news headlines |
|
|
Copyright © 2001-2010 College of Radiology, Academy of Medicine of Malaysia All Rights Reserved
Terms of Use Last Updated:
Monday, 04 January 2010 |
|